What are the different types of silage?

Forage harvester


The composition of the ensiled forage and the subsequent fermentation will determine the type of silage produced. Silages produced under Australian conditions can be broadly classified into five main types:

Lactate silages

  • Fermentation is dominated by Lactic Acid Bacteria (LAB);
  • Water Soluble Carbohydrates (WSCs) are primarily converted to lactic acid;
  • Have a pleasant, acidic and sometimes sweet smell;
  • pH values are generally low (3.8-4.2), except in heavily wilted silages where the fermentation is restricted; and
  • Contain high lactic acid levels relative to other organic acids.

Acetate silages

  • Fermentation may be dominated by enterobacteria;
  • More likely to occur when unwilted, or lightly wilted, low Dry Matter (DM) forage is ensiled;
  • WSCs are primarily converted to acetic acid;
  • Typified by a sour, vinegar smell;
  • pH values are higher than those of lactate silages at the same DM content; and
  • DM and energy losses can be significant.

Clostridial silages

  • Fermentation is dominated by clostridia;
  • More likely to occur when unwilted, or lightly wilted, low DM forage is ensiled;
  • WSCs and lactic acid are converted to butyric and acetic acid;
  • Characterised by low lactic acid levels and high pH;
  • Proteins and amino acids are extensively degraded;
  • Ammonia-N levels are high as a proportion of total N;
  • DM and energy losses can be significant (silages are unpalatable to livestock and the utilisation of the N in these silages is poor); and
  • Clostridial silages are not common in Australia.

Alfalfa used as a forage crop

Wilted silages

  • Fermentation is dominated by LAB;
  • Fermentation is restricted because of the high DM content (>30%). Less WSC are converted to lactic acid. pH values are higher than those of lactate silages;
  • Residual, unfermented WSC levels can be high, but vary due to length and extent of wilting;
  • Very dry forages are harder to compact, especially if chop length is long; there is a greater risk of yeast and mould growth because oxygen levels in the pit or bale are high in poorly compacted silages; and
  • Higher residual WSC, poor compaction and carry-over yeast and mould spores can make these silages more aerobically unstable.

Silages with additives

The characteristics and type of fermentation observed varies with additive type.